4th Cir., Jadhav, 2011*

United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
Docket for Case #: 11-2050

Lokesh Vuyyuru v. Gopinath Jadhav

Date Filed:  Sept. 29, 2011
Status:  Closed
Nature of suit:  3470 Civil (Rico)
Original Cases:  3:10-cv-00173-JRS on 03/16/2010, United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia at Richmond
District:  0422
NOA Date:  09/28/2011

Plaintiff – Appellant
LOKESH VUYYURU, M.D.
Mick G. Harrison
205 North College Avenue
Bloomington, IN 47404
Personal: 812-361-6220
[COR NTC Retained]
Steven D. Smith
SD SMITH, ESQUIRE, PLLC
2001 South Main Street
Blacksburg, VA 24060
Personal: 540-552-2525
[COR NTC Retained]

Plaintiff – Appellant
VIRGINIA GASTROENTEROLOGY ASSOCIATES PC
Mick G. Harrison
205 North College Avenue
Bloomington, IN 47404
Personal: 812-361-6220
[COR NTC Retained]
Steven D. Smith
SD SMITH, ESQUIRE, PLLC
2001 South Main Street
Blacksburg, VA 24060
Personal: 540-552-2525
[COR NTC Retained]

Plaintiff – Appellant
VIRGINIA TIMES, INCORPORATED
Mick G. Harrison
205 North College Avenue
Bloomington, IN 47404
Personal: 812-361-6220
[COR NTC Retained]
Steven D. Smith
SD SMITH, ESQUIRE, PLLC
2001 South Main Street
Blacksburg, VA 24060
Personal: 540-552-2525
[COR NTC Retained]

Defendant – Appellee
GOPINATH JADHAV, M.D.
Martin Andrew Donlan, Jr.
WILLIAMS MULLEN
200 South 10th Street
P. O. Box 1320
Richmond, VA 23218-1320
Personal: 804-783-6934
[On Brief]
William Benjamin Pace
WILLIAMS MULLEN
200 South 10th Street
P. O. Box 1320
Richmond, VA 23218-1320
Personal: 804-420-6932
[COR NTC Retained]

Defendant – Appellee
COMMUNITY HEALTH SYSTEMS PROFESSIONAL SERVICES, INCORPORATED
Bernard Page Gravely, Jr.
HANCOCK DANIEL JOHNSON & NAGLE, PC
4701 Cox Road
Glen Allen, VA 23060-0000
Personal: 804-967-9604
[On Brief]
Emily Munro Scott
HANCOCK DANIEL JOHNSON & NAGLE, PC
4701 Cox Road
Glen Allen, VA 23060-0000
Personal: 804-967-9604
[COR NTC Retained]

Defendant – Appellee
PETERSBURG HOSPITAL COMPANY, LLC, d/b/a Southside Regional Medical Center
Bernard Page Gravely, Jr.
HANCOCK DANIEL JOHNSON & NAGLE, PC
4701 Cox Road
Glen Allen, VA 23060-0000
Personal: 804-967-9604
[On Brief]
Emily Munro Scott
HANCOCK DANIEL JOHNSON & NAGLE, PC
4701 Cox Road
Glen Allen, VA 23060-0000
Personal: 804-967-9604
[COR NTC Retained]

Defendant – Appellee
COLUMBIA/HCA JOHN RANDOLPH, INCORPORATED
John William Boland
MCGUIREWOODS, LLP
1 James Center
901 East Cary Street
Richmond, VA 23219-4030
Personal: 804-775-4374
[COR LD NTC Retained]
Jeremy Stephen Byrum
MCGUIREWOODS, LLP
1 James Center
901 East Cary Street
Richmond, VA 23219-4030
Personal: 804-775-4305
[COR NTC Retained]
Nathan A. Kottkamp
MCGUIREWOODS, LLP
1 James Center
901 East Cary Street
Richmond, VA 23219-4030
Personal: 804-775-1092
[COR NTC Retained]

Defendant – Appellee
ANANT DAMLE, M.D.
David Edward Constine, III , Trial Attorney
TROUTMAN SANDERS, LLP
1001 Haxall Point
P. O. Box 1122
Richmond, VA 23218-1122
Personal: 804-697-1258
[COR NTC Retained]
Stephen Douglas Rosenthal
TROUTMAN SANDERS, LLP
1001 Haxall Point
P. O. Box 1122
Richmond, VA 23218-1122
Personal: 804-697-1219
[COR NTC Retained]

Defendant – Appellee
JUDITH W. JAGDMANN, in official capacity as then acting Virginia Attorney General
John David Gilbody
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF VIRGINIA
900 East Main Street
Richmond, VA 23219-0000
Personal: 804-786-8198
[COR NTC Government]
Wesley Glenn Russell, Jr.
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF VIRGINIA
900 East Main Street
Richmond, VA 23219-0000
[COR NTC Government]

Defendant – Appellee
DAVID FIKSE
Bernard Page Gravely, Jr.
HANCOCK DANIEL JOHNSON & NAGLE, PC
4701 Cox Road
Glen Allen, VA 23060-0000
Personal: 804-967-9604
[On Brief]
Emily Munro Scott
HANCOCK DANIEL JOHNSON & NAGLE, PC
4701 Cox Road
Glen Allen, VA 23060-0000
Personal: 804-967-9604
[COR NTC Retained]

Defendant – Appellee
LINDA AULT
John William Boland
MCGUIREWOODS, LLP
1 James Center
901 East Cary Street
Richmond, VA 23219-4030
Personal: 804-775-4374
[COR LD NTC Retained]
Jeremy Stephen Byrum
MCGUIREWOODS, LLP
1 James Center
901 East Cary Street
Richmond, VA 23219-4030
Personal: 804-775-4305
[COR NTC Retained]
Nathan A. Kottkamp
MCGUIREWOODS, LLP
1 James Center
901 East Cary Street
Richmond, VA 23219-4030
Personal: 804-775-1092
[COR NTC Retained]

Defendant – Appellee
FRANCIS WALTER PEDROTTY, III
John David Gilbody
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF VIRGINIA
900 East Main Street
Richmond, VA 23219-0000
Personal: 804-786-8198
[COR NTC Government]
Wesley Glenn Russell, Jr.
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF VIRGINIA
900 East Main Street
Richmond, VA 23219-0000
[COR NTC Government]

Defendant – Appellee
WILLIAM HARP, M.D.
John David Gilbody
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF VIRGINIA
900 East Main Street
Richmond, VA 23219-0000
Personal: 804-786-8198
[COR NTC Government]
Wesley Glenn Russell, Jr.
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF VIRGINIA
900 East Main Street
Richmond, VA 23219-0000
[COR NTC Government]

Defendant – Appellee
ROBERT NEBIKER
John David Gilbody
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF VIRGINIA
900 East Main Street
Richmond, VA 23219-0000
Personal: 804-786-8198
[COR NTC Government]
Wesley Glenn Russell, Jr.
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF VIRGINIA
900 East Main Street
Richmond, VA 23219-0000
[COR NTC Government]

Defendant – Appellee
JOHN STANWIX
John David Gilbody
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF VIRGINIA
900 East Main Street
Richmond, VA 23219-0000
Personal: 804-786-8198
[COR NTC Government]
Wesley Glenn Russell, Jr.
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF VIRGINIA
900 East Main Street
Richmond, VA 23219-0000
[COR NTC Government]

Defendant – Appellee
KAMLESH DAVE, M.D.
Bernard Page Gravely, Jr.
HANCOCK DANIEL JOHNSON & NAGLE, PC
4701 Cox Road
Glen Allen, VA 23060-0000
Personal: 804-967-9604
[On Brief]
Emily Munro Scott
HANCOCK DANIEL JOHNSON & NAGLE, PC
4701 Cox Road
Glen Allen, VA 23060-0000
Personal: 804-967-9604
[COR NTC Retained]

Defendant – Appellee
KENNETH T. CUCCINELLI, II, in his official capacity as then Virginia Attorney General
John David Gilbody
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF VIRGINIA
900 East Main Street
Richmond, VA 23219-0000
Personal: 804-786-8198
[COR NTC Government]
Wesley Glenn Russell, Jr.
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF VIRGINIA
900 East Main Street
Richmond, VA 23219-0000
[COR NTC Government]

Defendant – Appellee
SHARAD SARAIYA, M.D.
John William Boland
MCGUIREWOODS, LLP
1 James Center
901 East Cary Street
Richmond, VA 23219-4030
Personal: 804-775-4374
[COR LD NTC Retained]
Jeremy Stephen Byrum
MCGUIREWOODS, LLP
1 James Center
901 East Cary Street
Richmond, VA 23219-4030
Personal: 804-775-4305
[COR NTC Retained]
Nathan A. Kottkamp
MCGUIREWOODS, LLP
1 James Center
901 East Cary Street
Richmond, VA 23219-4030
Personal: 804-775-1092
[COR NTC Retained]

Defendant
SOUTHSIDE GASTROENTEROLOGY ASSOCIATES, LIMITED

Defendant
PETERSBURG HOSPITAL, INCORPORATED, d/b/a Southside Regional Medical Center

Defendant
CAMERON FOUNDATION, a Virginia Nonprofit Corporation

Defendant
VIRGINIA BOARD OF MEDICINE

Defendant
JERRY WALTER KILGORE, in former and official capacity and in individual capacity as Virginia Attorney General

Defendant
DAVID S. DUNHAM

Defendant
STEPHEN EDWARD HERETICK

Defendant
LYNN AUSTIN

Defendant
AKSHAY DAVE, M.D.

Defendant
JOHN DOE DEFENDANTS

Amicus Supporting Appellant
MICHAEL GOLDING, MD
Kara Lyn Reagan
STAFFORD LAW OFFICE, LLC
P. O. Box 2358
Bloomington, IN 47402
Personal: 812-339-6055
[COR NTC Retained]
Rudolph William Savich
409 South College Avenue
Bloomington, IN 47403
Personal: 812-336-7293
[COR NTC Retained]

Amicus Supporting Appellant
CHRISTOPHER T. MALLAVARAPU, MD
Kara Lyn Reagan
STAFFORD LAW OFFICE, LLC
P. O. Box 2358
Bloomington, IN 47402
Personal: 812-339-6055
[COR NTC Retained]
Rudolph William Savich
409 South College Avenue
Bloomington, IN 47403
Personal: 812-336-7293
[COR NTC Retained]

Amicus Supporting Appellant
ADDAGADDA C. RAO, MD
Kara Lyn Reagan
STAFFORD LAW OFFICE, LLC
P. O. Box 2358
Bloomington, IN 47402
Personal: 812-339-6055
[COR NTC Retained]
Rudolph William Savich
409 South College Avenue
Bloomington, IN 47403
Personal: 812-336-7293
[COR NTC Retained]

Docket Proceedings

Filed

Docket Text

Sept. 29, 2011

Case docketed. Originating case number: 3:10-cv-00173-JRS. Case manager: ACarlheim. Date notice of appeal filed: 09/28/2011 [11-2050] (ALC)

Sept. 30, 2011

DISTRICT COURT UPDATE. Transmission of ADDITIONAL Notice of Appeal to US Court of Appeals re [112] Notice of Appeal [11-2050] (JB)

Sept. 30, 2011

FEE NOTICE issued to Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC, Virginia Times, Incorporated and Lokesh Vuyyuru – initial notice. Fee or application to proceed as indigent due 10/17/2011. Originating case number: 3:10-cv-00173-JRS. Mailed to: Bernard Page Gravely Jr., Emily Munro Scott, Stephen Douglas Rosenthal. [11-2050] (ALC)

Sept. 30, 2011

DOCKETING NOTICE issued Re: ,case docketed. Initial forms due within 14 days. Originating case number: 3:10-cv-00173-JRS. Mailed to: Bernard Page Gravely Jr., Emily Munro Scott, Stephen Douglas Rosenthal. [11-2050] (ALC)

Sept. 30, 2011

BRIEFING ORDER filed. Mailed to: Bernard Page Gravely Jr., Emily Munro Scott, Stephen Douglas Rosenthal. Opening Brief and Appendix due 11/09/2011. Response Brief due 12/12/2011. [11-2050] (ALC)

Oct. 03, 2011

DISTRICT COURT UPDATE. USCA Appeal Fees RECEIVED: $455.00, Receipt Number: 34683014438 re: [112] (Additional) Notice of Appeal filed by Lokesh Vuyyuru and [110] Notice of Appeal filed by Lokesh Vuyyuru. (Attachment: # (1) Letter from Counsel for Plaintiffs). [11-2050] (JB)

Oct. 11, 2011

APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL (Local Rule 46(c)) by W. Benjamin Pace for Gopinath Jadhav.[998697340] [11-2050] William Pace

Oct. 11, 2011

DISCLOSURE OF CORPORATE AFFILIATIONS (Local Rule 26.1) by Appellee Gopinath Jadhav. Was any question on Disclosure Form answered yes? No [998697344] [11-2050] William Pace

Oct. 14, 2011

APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL (Local Rule 46(c)) by Stephen M. Hall for William Harp, Judith W. Jadgman, Robert F. McDonnell, Robert Nebiker, Francis Walter Pedrotty, III and John Stanwix.[998700867] [11-2050] Stephen Hall

Oct. 14, 2011

DISCLOSURE OF CORPORATE AFFILIATIONS (Local Rule 26.1) by Appellee William Harp. Was any question on Disclosure Form answered yes? No [998700872] [11-2050] Stephen Hall

Oct. 14, 2011

DISCLOSURE OF CORPORATE AFFILIATIONS (Local Rule 26.1) by Appellee Judith W. Jadgman. Was any question on Disclosure Form answered yes? No [998700874] [11-2050] Stephen Hall

Oct. 14, 2011

DISCLOSURE OF CORPORATE AFFILIATIONS (Local Rule 26.1) by Appellee Robert F. McDonnell. Was any question on Disclosure Form answered yes? No [998700878] [11-2050] Stephen Hall

Oct. 14, 2011

DISCLOSURE OF CORPORATE AFFILIATIONS (Local Rule 26.1) by Appellee Robert Nebiker. Was any question on Disclosure Form answered yes? No [998700880] [11-2050] Stephen Hall

Oct. 14, 2011

DISCLOSURE OF CORPORATE AFFILIATIONS (Local Rule 26.1) by Appellee Francis Walter Pedrotty, III. Was any question on Disclosure Form answered yes? No [998700882] [11-2050] Stephen Hall

Oct. 14, 2011

DISCLOSURE OF CORPORATE AFFILIATIONS (Local Rule 26.1) by Appellee John Stanwix. Was any question on Disclosure Form answered yes? No [998700883] [11-2050] Stephen Hall

Oct. 14, 2011

APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL (Local Rule 46(c)) by Steven D. Smith for Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC, Virginia Times, Incorporated and Lokesh Vuyyuru.[998700942] [11-2050] Steven Smith

Oct. 14, 2011

DISCLOSURE OF CORPORATE AFFILIATIONS (Local Rule 26.1) by Appellant Lokesh Vuyyuru. Was any question on Disclosure Form answered yes? No [998700946] [11-2050] Steven Smith

Oct. 14, 2011

DISCLOSURE OF CORPORATE AFFILIATIONS (Local Rule 26.1) by Appellant Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC. Was any question on Disclosure Form answered yes? No [998700947] [11-2050] Steven Smith

Oct. 14, 2011

DISCLOSURE OF CORPORATE AFFILIATIONS (Local Rule 26.1) by Appellant Virginia Times, Incorporated. Was any question on Disclosure Form answered yes? No [998700949] [11-2050] Steven Smith

Oct. 14, 2011

DOCKETING STATEMENT by Appellant Lokesh Vuyyuru. [11-2050] Steven Smith

Oct. 14, 2011

TRANSCRIPT ORDER FORM by Lokesh Vuyyuru for Jeffrey Kull (transcript ordered/entered in district court). [11-2050] Steven Smith

Oct. 14, 2011

APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL (Local Rule 46(c)) by J. William Boland for Linda Ault, Columbia/HCA John Randolph, Incorporated and Sharad Saraiya.[998700976] [11-2050] John Boland

Oct. 14, 2011

APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL (Local Rule 46(c)) by Nathan A. Kottkamp for Linda Ault, Columbia/HCA John Randolph, Incorporated and Sharad Saraiya.[998700994] [11-2050] Nathan Kottkamp

Oct. 14, 2011

APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL (Local Rule 46(c)) by Jeremy S. Byrum for Linda Ault, Columbia/HCA John Randolph, Incorporated and Sharad Saraiya.[998701006] [11-2050] Jeremy Byrum

Oct. 14, 2011

DISCLOSURE OF CORPORATE AFFILIATIONS (Local Rule 26.1) by Appellee Columbia/HCA John Randolph, Incorporated. Was any question on Disclosure Form answered yes? Yes [998701009] [11-2050] Jeremy Byrum

Oct. 14, 2011

DISCLOSURE OF CORPORATE AFFILIATIONS (Local Rule 26.1) by Appellee Linda Ault. Was any question on Disclosure Form answered yes? No [998701011] [11-2050] Jeremy Byrum

Oct. 14, 2011

DISCLOSURE OF CORPORATE AFFILIATIONS (Local Rule 26.1) by Appellee Sharad Saraiya. Was any question on Disclosure Form answered yes? No [998701013] [11-2050] Jeremy Byrum

Oct. 14, 2011

APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL (Local Rule 46(c)) by Stephen D. Rosenthal for Ananth Damle.[998701014] [11-2050] Stephen Rosenthal

Oct. 14, 2011

APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL (Local Rule 46(c)) by Emily Munro Scott for Community Health Systems Professional Services, Incorporated.[998701025] [11-2050] Emily Scott

Oct. 14, 2011

APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL (Local Rule 46(c)) by David E. Constine, III for Ananth Damle.[998701028] [11-2050] David Constine

Oct. 14, 2011

DISCLOSURE OF CORPORATE AFFILIATIONS (Local Rule 26.1) by Appellee Ananth Damle. Was any question on Disclosure Form answered yes? No [998701029] [11-2050] David Constine

Oct. 14, 2011

APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL (Local Rule 46(c)) by Emily Munro Scott for Petersburg Hospital Company, LLC.[998701031] [11-2050] Emily Scott

Oct. 14, 2011

APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL (Local Rule 46(c)) by Emily Munro Scott for Kamanesh Dave.[998701033] [11-2050] Emily Scott

Oct. 14, 2011

APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL (Local Rule 46(c)) by Emily Munro Scott for David Fikse.[998701034] [11-2050] Emily Scott

Oct. 14, 2011

DISCLOSURE OF CORPORATE AFFILIATIONS (Local Rule 26.1) by Appellee Community Health Systems Professional Services, Incorporated. Was any question on Disclosure Form answered yes? Yes [998701037] [11-2050] Emily Scott

Oct. 14, 2011

DISCLOSURE OF CORPORATE AFFILIATIONS (Local Rule 26.1) by Appellee Petersburg Hospital Company, LLC. Was any question on Disclosure Form answered yes? Yes [998701039] [11-2050] Emily Scott

Oct. 14, 2011

DISCLOSURE OF CORPORATE AFFILIATIONS (Local Rule 26.1) by Appellee Kamanesh Dave. Was any question on Disclosure Form answered yes? No [998701042] [11-2050] Emily Scott

Oct. 14, 2011

DISCLOSURE OF CORPORATE AFFILIATIONS (Local Rule 26.1) by Appellee David Fikse. Was any question on Disclosure Form answered yes? No [998701044] [11-2050] Emily Scott

Oct. 14, 2011

DESIGNATION OF LEAD COUNSEL (Local Rule 12(b)) by Appellees Linda Ault, Columbia/HCA John Randolph, Incorporated, Community Health Systems Professional Services, Incorporated, Ananth Damle, Kamanesh Dave, David Fikse, William Harp, Judith W. Jadgman, Gopinath Jadhav, Robert F. McDonnell, Robert Nebiker, Francis Walter Pedrotty, III, Petersburg Hospital Company, LLC, Sharad Saraiya and John Stanwix. Name of lead counsel: J. William Boland. [11-2050] Jeremy Byrum

Oct. 17, 2011

BRIEFING ORDER filed. – INCORRECT ENTRY STRUCK. BRIEFING ORDER ISSUED 09/30/2011 IN EFFECT. [Edited 10/17/2011 by ALC]f due 12/29/2011. [11-2050] (ALC)

Oct. 17, 2011

Initial mediation conference scheduled. [11-2050] (SLW)

Nov. 04, 2011

MOTION by Appellant Lokesh Vuyyuru to place case in abeyance for The Supreme Court recently granted certiorari in the case of Rehberg v. Paulk and oral argument on November 2nd, 2011. Appellants request that this case be put in abeyance until a decision is rendered by the Supreme Court in Rehberg. Alternatively,, to extend filing time for opening brief and appendix until January 23, 2012. Date and method of service: 11/04/2011 ecf [998717371] [11-2050] Steven Smith

Nov. 07, 2011

NOTICE ISSUED to Mr. John William Boland, Mr. Jeremy Stephen Byrum, and Mr. Nathan A. Kottkamp for Columbia/HCA John Randolph, Incorporated, Linda Ault and Sharad Saraiya; Mr. David Edward Constine, III and Mr. Stephen Douglas Rosenthal for Ananth Damle, Mr. Stephen Michael Hall for Robert F. McDonnell, Judith W. Jadgman, Francis Walter Pedrotty, III, William Harp, Robert Nebiker and John Stanwix; Mr. William Benjamin Pace for Gopinath Jadhav; and Emily Munro Scott for Community Health Systems Professional Services, Incorporated, Petersburg Hospital Company, LLC, David Fikse and Kamanesh Dave requesting response to Motion for abeyance (Local Rule 12(d)) or alternatively, to extend filing time for opening brief and appendix until January 23, 2012. Response due: 11/17/2011.[998717561]. [11-2050] (ALC)

Nov. 07, 2011

ORDER filed , suspending briefing schedule. Copies to all parties. [11-2050] (ALC)

Nov. 09, 2011

MOTION by for Substitution of counsel. Date and method of service: 11/09/2011 ecf [998719987] [11-2050] Stephen Hall

Nov. 09, 2011

ORDER filed , granting motion for withdrawing/relieving/substituting counsel. Name of new attorney: John D. Gilbody substituted as counsel for Commonwealth appellees. Copies to all parties. [11-2050] (ALC)

Nov. 09, 2011

APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL (Local Rule 46(c)) by John Gilbody for William Harp, Judith W. Jadgman, Robert F. McDonnell, Robert Nebiker, Francis Walter Pedrotty, III and John Stanwix.[998720220] [11-2050] John Gilbody

Nov. 17, 2011

RESPONSE/ANSWER by Linda Ault, Columbia/HCA John Randolph, Incorporated, Community Health Systems Professional Services, Incorporated, Ananth Damle, Kamanesh Dave, David Fikse, William Harp, Judith W. Jadgman, Gopinath Jadhav, Robert F. McDonnell, Robert Nebiker, Francis Walter Pedrotty, III, Petersburg Hospital Company, LLC, Sharad Saraiya and John Stanwix to Motion for abeyance (Local Rule 12(d)) . Nature of response: in opposition. [11-2050] Jeremy Byrum

Nov. 22, 2011

COURT ORDER filed . Copies to all parties. [11-2050] (ALC)

Nov. 22, 2011

BRIEFING ORDER filed. Opening Brief and Appendix due 01/03/2012. Response Brief due 02/03/2012. [11-2050] (ALC)

Jan. 03, 2012

APPENDIX (PAPER) file-stamped – DUPLICATE ENTRY STRUCK, [11-2050]–[Edited 01/12/2012 by ALC] (JHM)

Jan. 03, 2012

OPENING BRIEF (PAPER) file-stamped, on behalf of Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC, Virginia Times, Incorporated and Lokesh Vuyyuru. Number of pages: [72]. Sufficient: YES. Entered on Docket Date: 01/05/2012. [998758987] [11-2050] (ALC)

Jan. 03, 2012

APPENDIX (PAPER) file-stamped, on behalf of Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC, Virginia Times, Incorporated and Lokesh Vuyyuru. Total number of volumes (including any sealed): 4. Total number of pages in all volumes: 1723. Total number of sealed volumes: 0. Sufficient? No. CD/DVD/Other exhibit? No. Entered on Docket Date: 01/06/2012. [998759339] [11-2050] (ALC)

Jan. 04, 2012

MOTION by Appellant Lokesh Vuyyuru to extend filing time for opening brief. Date and method of service: 01/03/2012 ecf [998756598] [11-2050] Steven Smith

Jan. 04, 2012

ORDER filed , updating/ resuming briefing order deadlines. Opening brief and appendix due 01/04/2012. Response brief due 02/06/2012 Copies to all parties. [11-2050] (DHB)

Jan. 04, 2012

NOTICE OF PAPER FILING by Appellant Lokesh Vuyyuru. Type of paper document filed: appendix Date paper copies mailed, dispatched or delivered to court: 01/03/2012 Method of filing paper copies: hand delivery [11-2050] Steven Smith

Jan. 04, 2012

MEMORANDUM OPENING BRIEF – INCORRECT ENTRY STRUCK [11-2050]–[Edited 01/05/2012 by ALC] Steven Smith

Jan. 05, 2012

Docket correction requested from Mr. Steven D. Smith, Esq. for Lokesh Vuyyuru, Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC and Virginia Times, Incorporated. Re: memorandum opening Brief. Docket entry will be struck upon completion of filing correction. [11-2050] (ALC)

Jan. 05, 2012

BRIEF by Appellant Lokesh Vuyyuru in electronic and paper format. Type of Brief: Opening. Method of Filing Paper Copies: hand delivery. [998757822] [11-2050] Steven Smith

Jan. 06, 2012

Docket correction requested from Mr. Steven D. Smith, Esq. for Lokesh Vuyyuru, Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC and Virginia Times, Incorporated. Re: [59] appendix. [11-2050] (ALC)

Jan. 09, 2012

NOTICE OF PAPER FILING by Appellant Lokesh Vuyyuru. Type of paper document filed: Corrected appendix Date paper copies mailed, dispatched or delivered to court: 01/09/2012 Method of filing paper copies: hand delivery [11-2050]–[Text Edited 01/09/2012 by ALC] Steven Smith

Jan. 09, 2012

CORRECTED APPENDIX (PAPER) file-stamped on behalf of Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC, Virginia Times, Incorporated and Lokesh Vuyyuru correcting and superseding appendix [59]. Total number of volumes (including sealed volumes): 4 (of which 3 are Exhibit Volumes). Total number of sealed volumes: 0. Total number of pages in all volumes: 1723. Entered on Docket Date: 01/09/2012. [998761269] [11-2050] (ALC)

Jan. 11, 2012

MOTION by International Association of Whistleblowers. Amicus Curiae to approve/authorize Amicus Curiae Brief filed simultaneously. Date and method of service: 01/11/2012 ecf [998763538] [11-2050] Glenn Goodhart

Jan. 11, 2012

AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF by International Association of Whistleblowers – ENTRY STRUCK. [998763539] [11-2050]–[Edited 01/12/2012 by ALC] Glenn Goodhart

Jan. 12, 2012

Docket correction requested from Glenn L. Goodhart for International Association of Whistleblowers. Re: amicus curiae Brief. Access to amicus curiae Brief has been restricted to case participants and will be struck upon corrected filing. [11-2050] (ALC)

Jan. 12, 2012

MOTION by Potential Amicus Curiae International Association of Whistleblowers to approve/authorize Withdrawal of motion to accept amicus brief and withdrawal of amicus brief. Date and method of service: 01/12/2012 ecf [998763863] [11-2050] Glenn Goodhart

Jan. 12, 2012

MOTION by Dr. Christopher T. Mallavarapu to extend filing time for Amicus Brief until 01/16/2012. Date and method of service: 01/11/2012 Courier delivery [998763953] [11-2050] (ALC)

Jan. 12, 2012

ORDER filed . Copies to all parties. [11-2050] (ALC)

Jan. 12, 2012

ORDER filed . Motion for leave to file amicus brief and proposed amicus brief due 01/17/2012. Copies to all parties. Mailed to: Christopher Mallavarapu. [11-2050] (ALC)

Jan. 13, 2012

MOTION by Dr. Michael Golding to extend filing time for Amicus Brief until 01/16/2012. Date and method of service: 01/12/2012 Courier delivery [998765096] [11-2050] (ALC)

Jan. 13, 2012

MOTION by Dr. Addagadda C. Rao to extend filing time for Amicus Brief until 01/16/2012. Date and method of service: 01/12/2012 Courier delivery [998765097] [11-2050] (ALC)

Jan. 13, 2012

ORDER filed . Motion for leave to file amicus brief and proposed amicus brief due 01/17/2012. Copies to all parties. Mailed to: Addagadda Rao, Christopher Mallavarapu, and Michael Golding. [11-2050] (ALC)

Jan. 13, 2012

ORDER filed . Motion for leave to file amicus brief and proposed amicus brief due 01/17/2012. Copies to all parties. Mailed to: Dr. Addagadda Rao, Dr. Christopher Mallavarapu, and Dr. Michael Golding. [11-2050] (ALC)

Jan. 17, 2012

APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL (Local Rule 46(c)) by Kara L. Reagan for Michael Golding, MD, Christopher T. Mallavarapu, MD and Addagadda C. Rao, MD.[998766849] [11-2050] Kara Reagan

Jan. 17, 2012

MOTION by Potential Amici Curiae Michael Golding, MD, Christopher T. Mallavarapu, MD and Addagadda C. Rao, MD to file amicus curiae brief (FRAP 29(e)) without consent of all parties on appeal within time allowed by FRAP 29(e).. Date and method of service: 01/17/2012 ecf [998766850] [11-2050] Kara Reagan

Jan. 17, 2012

AMICUS CURIAE/INTERVENOR BRIEF by Potential Amici Curiae Michael Golding, MD, Christopher T. Mallavarapu, MD and Addagadda C. Rao, MD in electronic and paper format. Type of Brief: Amicus Curiae. Method of Filing Paper Copies: hand delivery. Date Paper Copies Mailed, Dispatched, or Delivered to Court: 01/17/2012. [998766851] [11-2050] –[Disclosure Statement Added 01/18/2012 by ALC] Kara Reagan

Jan. 17, 2012

DISCLOSURE OF CORPORATE AFFILIATIONS (Local Rule 26.1) by Potential Amici Curiae Michael Golding, MD, Christopher T. Mallavarapu, MD and Addagadda C. Rao, MD. Was any question on Disclosure Form answered yes? No [998766852] [11-2050] Kara Reagan

Jan. 18, 2012

NOTICE ISSUED to Mr. Steven D. Smith, Esq. for Lokesh Vuyyuru, Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC and Virginia Times, Incorporated; to Mr. John William Boland, Mr. Jeremy Stephen Byrum, and Mr. Nathan A. Kottkamp for Columbia/HCA John Randolph, Incorporated, Linda Ault and Sharad Saraiya; to Mr. David Edward Constine, III and Mr. Stephen Douglas Rosenthal for Ananth Damle; to Mr. John David Gilbody for Mr. Kenneth T. Cuccinelli, II, Judith W. Jadgman, Francis Walter Pedrotty, III, William Harp, Robert Nebiker and John Stanwix; to Mr. William Benjamin Pace for Gopinath Jadhav: and to Emily Munro Scott for Community Health Systems Professional Services, Inc., Petersburg Hospital Company, LLC, David Fikse and Kamanesh Dave requesting response to Motion to file amicus curiae brief . Response due: 01/30/2012.[998767023]. [11-2050] (ALC)

Jan. 30, 2012

RESPONSE/ANSWER by Linda Ault, Columbia/HCA John Randolph, Incorporated, Community Health Systems Professional Services, Incorporated, Mr. Kenneth T. Cuccinelli, II, Ananth Damle, Kamanesh Dave, David Fikse, William Harp, Judith W. Jadgman, Gopinath Jadhav, Robert Nebiker, Francis Walter Pedrotty, III, Petersburg Hospital Company, LLC, Sharad Saraiya and John Stanwix to notice requesting response . [11-2050] Jeremy Byrum

Jan. 31, 2012

RESPONSE FOLLOW-UP NOTICE ISSUED to Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC, Virginia Times, Incorporated and Lokesh Vuyyuru. Response due on 02/10/2012. [11-2050] (ALC)

Feb. 06, 2012

BRIEF by Appellees Linda Ault, Columbia/HCA John Randolph, Incorporated, Community Health Systems Professional Services, Incorporated, Mr. Kenneth T. Cuccinelli, II, Ananth Damle, Kamanesh Dave, David Fikse, William Harp, Judith W. Jadgman, Gopinath Jadhav, Robert Nebiker, Francis Walter Pedrotty, III, Petersburg Hospital Company, LLC, Sharad Saraiya and John Stanwix in electronic and paper format. Type of Brief: Response. Method of Filing Paper Copies: hand delivery. Date Paper Copies Mailed, Dispatched, or Delivered to Court: 02/06/2012. [998782076] [11-2050] Jeremy Byrum

Feb. 06, 2012

MOTION by Appellees Linda Ault, Columbia/HCA John Randolph, Incorporated, Community Health Systems Professional Services, Incorporated, Mr. Kenneth T. Cuccinelli, II, Ananth Damle, Kamanesh Dave, David Fikse, William Harp, Judith W. Jadgman, Gopinath Jadhav, Robert Nebiker, Francis Walter Pedrotty, III, Petersburg Hospital Company, LLC, Sharad Saraiya and John Stanwix to impose sanctions.. Date and method of service: 02/06/2012 ecf [998782087] [11-2050] Jeremy Byrum

Feb. 06, 2012

RESPONSE BRIEF (PAPER) file-stamped, on behalf of Linda Ault, Columbia/HCA John Randolph, Incorporated, Community Health Systems Professional Services, Incorporated, Mr. Kenneth T. Cuccinelli, II, Ananth Damle, Kamanesh Dave, David Fikse, William Harp, Judith W. Jadgman, Gopinath Jadhav, Robert Nebiker, Francis Walter Pedrotty, III, Petersburg Hospital Company, LLC, Sharad Saraiya and John Stanwix. Number of pages: [94]. Sufficient: YES. Entered on Docket Date: 02/07/2012. [998782410] [11-2050] (ALC)

Feb. 07, 2012

NOTICE ISSUED to Mr. Steven D. Smith, Esq. for Lokesh Vuyyuru, Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC and Virginia Times, Incorporated requesting response to Motion to impose sanctions . Response due: 02/21/2012. [998782346]. [11-2050] (ALC)

Feb. 10, 2012

RESPONSE/ANSWER by Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC, Virginia Times, Incorporated and Lokesh Vuyyuru to notice requesting response . Nature of response: in support of. [11-2050] –[Docket Text Edited 02/13/2012 by ALC] Steven Smith

Feb. 13, 2012

ORDER filed . Copies to all parties. [11-2050] (ALC)

Feb. 13, 2012

AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF (PAPER) file-stamped, on behalf of Michael Golding, MD, Christopher T. Mallavarapu, MD and Addagadda C. Rao, MD. Number of pages: [25]. Entered on Docket Date: 02/13/2012.[998786695] [11-2050] (ALC)

Feb. 16, 2012

MOTION by Appellant Lokesh Vuyyuru to extend filing time for response to motion for sanctions until March 15, 2012. Date and method of service: 02/16/2012 ecf [998790735] [11-2050] Steven Smith

Feb. 17, 2012

ORDER filed . Copies to all parties. [11-2050] (ALC)

Feb. 21, 2012

RESPONSE/ANSWER – ENTRY STRUCK –[Edited 02/22/2012 by ALC] Steven Smith

Feb. 22, 2012

Corrected RESPONSE/ANSWER by Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC, Virginia Times, Incorporated and Lokesh Vuyyuru to Motion to impose sanctions . Nature of response: in opposition. [11-2050]–[Docket Text Edited 02/22/2012 by ALC] Steven Smith

Feb. 24, 2012

MOTION by Appellants Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC, Virginia Times, Incorporated and Lokesh Vuyyuru to extend filing time for reply brief until 2/25/2012. Date and method of service: 02/24/2012 ecf [998796476] [11-2050] Steven Smith

Feb. 27, 2012

MOTION by Appellants Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC, Virginia Times, Incorporated and Lokesh Vuyyuru leave to file Reply Brief Out of Time. Date and method of service: 02/27/2012 ecf [998797562] [11-2050] Steven Smith

Feb. 27, 2012

BRIEF by Appellants Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC, Virginia Times, Incorporated and Lokesh Vuyyuru in electronic and paper format. Type of Brief: Reply. Method of Filing Paper Copies: hand delivery. Date Paper Copies Mailed, Dispatched, or Delivered to Court: 02/27/2012. [998797568] [11-2050] Steven Smith

Feb. 27, 2012

ORDER filed , extending filing time for reply brief until 02/27/2012. Copies to all parties. [11-2050] (ALC)

Feb. 27, 2012

REPLY BRIEF (PAPER) file-stamped, on behalf of Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC, Virginia Times, Incorporated and Lokesh Vuyyuru. Number of pages: [37]. Sufficient: YES. Entered on Docket Date: 02/28/2012. [998797809] [11-2050] (ALC)

Feb. 28, 2012

REPLY by Linda Ault, Columbia/HCA John Randolph, Incorporated, Community Health Systems Professional Services, Incorporated, Mr. Kenneth T. Cuccinelli, II, Ananth Damle, Kamanesh Dave, David Fikse, William Harp, Judith W. Jadgman, Gopinath Jadhav, Robert Nebiker, Francis Walter Pedrotty, III, Petersburg Hospital Company, LLC, Sharad Saraiya and John Stanwix to Response . [11-2050] John Gilbody

May 25, 2012

MOTION by Appellants Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC, Virginia Times, Incorporated and Lokesh Vuyyuru to strike document portion of defendant-appellees’ motion for sanctions.. Date and method of service: 05/25/2012 ecf. [998862304] [11-2050] Steven Smith

May 25, 2012

NOTICE ISSUED to Mr. John William Boland, Mr. Jeremy Stephen Byrum, and Mr. Nathan A. Kottkamp for Columbia/HCA John Randolph, Inc., Linda Ault and Sharad Saraiya; to Mr. David Edward Constine, III and Mr. Stephen Douglas Rosenthal for Ananth Damle; to Mr. John David Gilbody for Mr. Kenneth T. Cuccinelli, II, Judith W. Jadgman, Francis Walter Pedrotty, III, William Harp, Robert Nebiker and John Stanwix; to Mr. William Benjamin Pace for Gopinath Jadhav: and to Emily Munro Scott for Community Health Systems Professional Services, Inc., Petersburg Hospital Company, LLC, David Fikse and Kamanesh Dave requesting response to Motion to strike . Response(s) due: 06/07/2012.[998862360] [11-2050] (ALC)

June 07, 2012

MOTION – ENTRY STRUCK. Correct docket entry has been made. [11-2050]–[Edited 06/07/2012 by ALC] John Gilbody

June 07, 2012

RESPONSE/ANSWER by Linda Ault, Columbia/HCA John Randolph, Incorporated, Community Health Systems Professional Services, Incorporated, Mr. Kenneth T. Cuccinelli, II, Ananth Damle, Kamanesh Dave, David Fikse, William Harp, Judith W. Jadgman, Gopinath Jadhav, Robert Nebiker, Francis Walter Pedrotty, III, Petersburg Hospital Company, LLC, Sharad Saraiya and John Stanwix to Motion to strike . Nature of response: in opposition. [11-2050] John Gilbody

June 07, 2012

ORDER filed . Copies to all parties. [11-2050] (ALC)

June 08, 2012

CASE TENTATIVELY CALENDARED for oral argument during the 9/18/12 – 9/21/12 argument session. Notify Clerk’s Office of any scheduling conflict by: 06/18/2012 [11-2050] (JLC)

June 11, 2012

NOTICE RE: CONFLICT WITH PROPOSED ARGUMENT DATES by Appellee Gopinath Jadhav. Argument Session: 9/18/12 to 9/21/12 Days you are available: 9/18/12, 9/20/12 and 9/21/12 [11-2050] William Pace

June 15, 2012

REPLY by Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC, Virginia Times, Incorporated and Lokesh Vuyyuru to Response . [11-2050] Steven Smith

June 18, 2012

NOTICE RE: CONFLICT WITH PROPOSED ARGUMENT DATES by Appellants Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC, Virginia Times, Incorporated and Lokesh Vuyyuru. Argument Session: 9/18/12 – 9/21/12 Days you are available: 9/18/12, 9/19/12, 9/20/12 [11-2050] Steven Smith

June 29, 2012

CASE CALENDARED for oral argument. Date: 09/18/2012. Registration Time: 8:45 – 9:00. Daily Arguments Begin: 9:30. [11-2050] (JLC)

July 03, 2012

ORAL ARGUMENT ACKNOWLEDGMENT by Appellee Gopinath Jadhav. [998888271] [11-2050] William Pace

July 03, 2012

ORAL ARGUMENT ACKNOWLEDGMENT by Appellee Columbia/HCA John Randolph, Incorporated. Counsel arguing: Jeremy S. Byrum Answering argument time: 0 minutes [998888334] [11-2050] Jeremy Byrum

July 03, 2012

APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL (Local Rule 46(c)) by Wesley G. Russell, Jr. for Mr. Kenneth T. Cuccinelli, II, William Harp, Judith W. Jadgman, Robert Nebiker, Francis Walter Pedrotty, III and John Stanwix.[998888350] [11-2050] Wesley Russell

July 03, 2012

ORAL ARGUMENT ACKNOWLEDGMENT by Appellees Mr. Kenneth T. Cuccinelli, II, William Harp, Judith W. Jadgman, Robert Nebiker, Francis Walter Pedrotty, III and John Stanwix. Counsel arguing: Wesley G. Russell, Jr. Answering argument time: 10 minutes [998888356] [11-2050] Wesley Russell

July 05, 2012

ORAL ARGUMENT ACKNOWLEDGMENT by Appellants Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC, Virginia Times, Incorporated and Lokesh Vuyyuru. Counsel arguing: MICK HARRISON [998889104] [11-2050] Steven Smith

July 05, 2012

ORAL ARGUMENT ACKNOWLEDGMENT- ENTRY STRUCK [11-2050]–[Edited 09/17/2012 by ALC] Kara Reagan

July 13, 2012

COURT ORDER filed . Copies to all parties. [11-2050] (ALC)

Aug. 31, 2012

APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL (Local Rule 46(c)) by Mick G. Harrison for Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC, Virginia Times, Incorporated and Lokesh Vuyyuru.[998929350] [11-2050] Mick Harrison

Sept. 11, 2012

MOTION by Amici Supporting Appellant Michael Golding, MD, Christopher T. Mallavarapu, MD, Addagadda C. Rao, MD and Appellants Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC, Virginia Times, Incorporated and Lokesh Vuyyuru to participate in oral argument. Date and method of service: 09/11/2012 ecf. [998935939] [11-2050] Mick Harrison

Sept. 12, 2012

NOTICE ISSUED to Mr. John William Boland, Mr. Jeremy Stephen Byrum, and Mr. Nathan A. Kottkamp for Columbia/HCA John Randolph, Inc., Linda Ault and Sharad Saraiya; to Mr. David Edward Constine, III and Mr. Stephen Douglas Rosenthal for Ananth Damle; to Mr. John David Gilbody for Mr. Kenneth T. Cuccinelli, II, Judith W. Jadgman, Francis Walter Pedrotty, III, William Harp, Robert Nebiker and John Stanwix; to Mr. William Benjamin Pace for Gopinath Jadhav: and to Emily Munro Scott for Community Health Systems Professional Services, Inc., Petersburg Hospital Company, LLC, David Fikse and Kamanesh Dave requesting response to Motion to participate in oral argument . RESPONSE DUE: 09/13/2012.[998936199] [11-2050] (ALC)

Sept. 12, 2012

APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL (Local Rule 46(c)) by Rudolph Wm. Savich for Michael Golding, MD, Christopher T. Mallavarapu, MD and Addagadda C. Rao, MD.[998936587] [11-2050] Rudolph Savich

Sept. 13, 2012

RESPONSE/ANSWER by Linda Ault, Columbia/HCA John Randolph, Incorporated, Community Health Systems Professional Services, Incorporated, Mr. Kenneth T. Cuccinelli, II, Ananth Damle, Kamanesh Dave, David Fikse, William Harp, Judith W. Jadgman, Gopinath Jadhav, Robert Nebiker, Francis Walter Pedrotty, III, Petersburg Hospital Company, LLC, Sharad Saraiya and John Stanwix to Motion to participate in oral argument . [11-2050] John Gilbody

Sept. 14, 2012

AMENDED RESPONSE/ANSWER by Linda Ault, Columbia/HCA John Randolph, Incorporated, Community Health Systems Professional Services, Incorporated, Mr. Kenneth T. Cuccinelli, II, Ananth Damle, Kamanesh Dave, David Fikse, William Harp, Judith W. Jadgman, Gopinath Jadhav, Robert Nebiker, Francis Walter Pedrotty, III, Petersburg Hospital Company, LLC, Sharad Saraiya and John Stanwix to notice requesting response . [11-2050] John Gilbody

Sept. 17, 2012

COURT ORDER filed . Copies to all parties. [11-2050] (ALC)

Sept. 17, 2012

ORAL ARGUMENT ACKNOWLEDGMENT by Amici Supporting Appellant Michael Golding, MD, Christopher T. Mallavarapu, MD and Addagadda C. Rao, MD. Counsel arguing: Rudolph Wm. Savich Opening argument time: 5 min [998939152] [11-2050] Rudolph Savich

Sept. 18, 2012

ORAL ARGUMENT heard before the Honorable William B. Traxler, Jr., Albert Diaz and Stephanie D. Thacker. Attorneys arguing case: Mr. Rudolph William Savich for Amici Supporting Appellant Christopher T. Mallavarapu, MD, Addagadda C. Rao, MD and Michael Golding, MD, Mr. Mick G. Harrison for Appellants Lokesh Vuyyuru, Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC and Virginia Times, Incorporated, Mr. William Benjamin Pace for Appellee Gopinath Jadhav and Mr. Wesley Glenn Russell, Jr., Esq. for Appellees Mr. Kenneth T. Cuccinelli, II, Judith W. Jadgman, Francis Walter Pedrotty, III, William Harp, Robert Nebiker and John Stanwix. Courtroom Deputy: Lisa Robertson. [998941039] [11-2050] (LER)

Dec. 27, 2012

UNPUBLISHED PER CURIAM OPINION filed. Motion disposition in opinion–denying Motion to impose sanctions Originating case number: 3:10-cv-00173-JRS Copies to all parties and the district court/agency. [999010635].. [11-2050] (MR)

Dec. 27, 2012

JUDGMENT ORDER filed. Disposition method: 11-2050 opn.u.arg. Decision: Affirmed. Originating case number: 3:10-cv-00173-JRS. Entered on Docket Date: 12/27/2012. [999010645] Copies to all parties and the district court/agency.. [11-2050] (MR)

Jan. 11, 2013

PETITION for rehearing and rehearing en banc (FRAP 35) by Appellants Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC, Virginia Times, Incorporated and Lokesh Vuyyuru. [11-2050]–[Edited 01/11/2013 by MFT] Mick Harrison

Jan. 11, 2013

MOTION by Appellants Virginia Gastroenterology Associates PC, Virginia Times, Incorporated and Lokesh Vuyyuru to extend filing time for petition for rehearing until January 11, 2013. Date and method of service: 01/11/2013 ecf. [999020312] [11-2050] Mick Harrison

Jan. 11, 2013

ORDER filed . Copies to all parties. [11-2050] (ALC)

Jan. 11, 2013

Mandate stayed by FRAP 41(d)(1). [11-2050] (ALC)

Jan. 23, 2013

COURT ORDER filed . Copies to all parties. [11-2050] (ALC)

Jan. 31, 2013

Mandate issued referencing: Judgment order. Originating case number: 3:10-cv-00173-JRS. [11-2050] (ALC)

Apr. 26, 2013

SUPREME COURT REMARK–petition for writ of certiorari filed. 04/23/2013. 12-1277. [11-2050] (AW)

June 25, 2013

SUPREME COURT REMARK–petition for writ of certiorari denied. 06/24/2013 [11-2050] (DHB)